0.jpg
1 / 42

280 Tally Ho, Arroyo Grande, CA 93420

$899K3bd · 2ba · 1,368 sqft
Lot 12,135 sqft•Single Family Residence•
Active
•44d on market•MLS# NS-26212519

Property Description

Just over a half mile from Arroyo Grande's Historic Village, 280 Tally Ho Road offers a serene blend of nature and privacy, with a beautifully renovated 1930s farmhouse and detached cottage, all within a few blocks of the Village's charming shops and dining! Thoroughly remodeled over the past five years, the home showcases modern finishes throughout. The kitchen features shaker cabinets, honed dark quartz countertops, and a stylish hexagon mosaic backsplash, and the remodeled bathrooms offer white subway tile and custom vanities. Additional upgrades include wide plank flooring, dual-pane windows, recessed LED lighting, hand-troweled drywall, fresh paint, new doors, a newer furnace, and upgraded plumbing and electrical. The main level offers two bedrooms and two bathrooms, including a spacious primary suite overlooking the colorful and bright front yard space. A spiral staircase leads upstairs to a large 3rd loft bedroom option also with its own exterior entrance. The detached cottage has a full bathroom and stylish finishes, making it perfect for weekend visitors or as a home office or gym. The Creekside setting creates an incredible microclimate, with established tangerine, pear, plum, passionfruit, and blackberry plantings and plenty of room for a garden. Set on nearly a third of an acre, the backyard is perfect for pets and playtime on the grass. Decomposed granite pathways wind through the space to a firepit for gathering in the evening, and a shed, swing set, and small chicken coop complete this peaceful retreat. A Trex deck leads out to the front yard, and a large concrete patio sits between the home and cottage in back. The extra-long driveway offers plenty of parking, and the detached two-car garage is a pull-through, providing access to the backyard. Tally Ho is a one-of-a-kind neighborhood, friendly and quiet, just 15 minutes from downtown San Luis Obispo and the beach! Seller financing or 2/1 rate buy down being offered by seller with an acceptable offer!

Features & Amenities

FeeBuilt 1938

Property Details

Land Type
Fee
Year Built
1938
Property Type
Residential
Property Subtype
Single Family Residence
Parking Spaces
2
Garage Spaces
2
Heating
Forced Air, High Efficiency
Cooling
None
View
Creek/Stream, Trees/Woods
Flooring
Wood
Roof
Shingle, Composition
City
Arroyo Grande
Zip Code
93420
County
San Luis Obispo
Listed byGUIDE Real Estate, Jacob Rodrigues

Mortgage Calculator

Current Rates

$
$
%
Monthly Payment
$4,545.83
Principal & Interest
Loan Amount
$719,200
Total Interest
$917,300
Total Payment Over 30 Years
$1,636,500
This calculator provides estimates only. Actual mortgage payments may include taxes, insurance, HOA fees, and PMI. Contact a lender for accurate quotes.

Comparative Market Analysis

Affordable Tier · 5 active · 5 closed

280 Tally Ho, Arroyo Grande, CA 93420

Arroyo Grande · Single Family Residence

$899K
Affordable Tier
Beds
3
Baths
2
Sqft
1,368
Lot
12,135 sqft
Year
1938
$/Sqft
$657
Pool: No✓
Spa: No✓
View: Creek/Stream, Trees/Woods✓
Garage: 2-car✓

Listed in line with the median closed sale of $900,000. Price per sqft ($657) is a 25% premium to closed comps ($525).

Price Position

Aligned with the market — fair pricing for the comps.

At market
Subject listed at $899K· $657/sqft
Total list price
Closed comps
vs closed median $900K
−$1K (−0.1%)
Active comps
vs active median $899K
$0 (0.0%)
Price per sqft
Closed compsinsufficient comp data
Active comps
vs active avg $/sqft $546
+$111 (+20.3%)

Active Properties (5)

Active Comparables

AddressCityYearBDBTHSqFtLotSzLP/SqFtLPDIMScore
864 Willow LaneArroyo Grande1960321,5127,860$608$919,0003775
903 Sandalwood AvenueArroyo Grande1955321,5566,333$513$799,0005573
1631 ChiltonArroyo Grande1970321,4645,365$614$899,0001272
350 WalnutArroyo Grande1951321,8579,869$511$949,0005071
1155 Stonecrest DriveArroyo Grande2004331,7106,036$485$829,0001168
Total: 5 · Average3.02.21,619.87,092.6$546.2$879,00033
Median1,556$899,000

Closed Properties (5)

Closed Comparables

AddressCityYearDateBDBTHSqFtLotSzLPSPSP/SqFtSP/LPDIMScore
614 Harrison StreetArroyo Grande197301/02/2026321,5095,355$899,000$900,000$5961.002978
411 Spanish MossArroyo Grande198905/13/2026321,6085,417$889,000$885,000$5501.003477
231 Oakwood CourtArroyo Grande198904/15/2026221,6400$875,000$830,000$5060.953177
407 ChaparralArroyo Grande198907/31/2026421,5758,102$949,000$960,000$6101.014376
571 Traffic WayArroyo Grande194907/13/2026442,47520,050$989,000$900,000$3640.9114255
Total: 5 · Average3.22.41,761.49,731$895,000$895,000$525.2—55.8
Median1,608$900,000$900,000

Market Analysis

List vs Sale $/SqFt

Sale Price Trend

Days on Market

Sale vs List Price

AI-generated CMA

This analysis was generated automatically from MLS data. For an in-depth, human-reviewed valuation, contact Joseph Sardella at josephsardella@gmail.com.