Listing cover photo
1 / 1

258 East Alegria, Sierra Madre, CA 91024

$3.99M5bd · 5ba · 5,310 sqft
Lot 20,515 sqft•Single Family Residence•
Active
•13d on market•MLS# SR-26236137

Property Description

In the foothills of highly sought-after Sierra Madre, on nearly half an acre, sits a two-story Craftsman with timeless character and an inviting sense of home. Classic charm and handcrafted detail meet the conveniences of modern living. Step inside and the craftsmanship greets you at every turn. There are classic Craftsman windows, rich mahogany crown moldings and baseboards, and beamed ceilings. Hand-crafted light fixtures cast a warm glow over the woodwork and detailing. Three fireplaces anchor the home, including a decorative Batchelder fireplace, a true collector’s piece. A built-in buffet and sideboard set the stage for memorable dinners, and French doors invite the outdoors in. Every room is generously sized, and tranquil mountain views fill most of them. The extra-large primary suite is a retreat of its own. It opens to a private spa-style bath with a sauna, a Jacuzzi tub, his-and-hers sinks and a walk-in closet. Outside, the home becomes a private retreat. Nearly 1,000 square feet of covered patio overlooks a secluded backyard with a sparkling pool, spa, outdoor kitchen and fire pit. It’s equally suited to a lively gathering of friends or a quiet candlelit dinner with family. Life here comes with the best of village living. The charming shops, cafés and restaurants of Sierra Madre Village are just moments away, ready for a morning coffee, a stroll through local boutiques or dinner with friends. When you want more, Pasadena and Arcadia are about 10 minutes away, and San Gabriel is just a few minutes beyond. Central air and heat, a large basement for storage, and an updated driveway round out the offering. With a little TLC, this could be the dream home for years to come.

Features & Amenities

FeeBuilt 1910

Property Details

Land Type
Fee
Year Built
1910
Property Type
Residential
Property Subtype
Single Family Residence
Heating
Central
Cooling
Central Air, None
View
Mountain(s)
Flooring
Tile, Wood
Roof
Composition
City
Sierra Madre
Zip Code
91024
County
Los Angeles
Listed byRodeo Realty, Moe Abourched

Mortgage Calculator

Current Rates

$
$
%
Monthly Payment
$20,165.50
Principal & Interest
Loan Amount
$3,190,400
Total Interest
$4,069,179
Total Payment Over 30 Years
$7,259,579
This calculator provides estimates only. Actual mortgage payments may include taxes, insurance, HOA fees, and PMI. Contact a lender for accurate quotes.

Comparative Market Analysis

Luxury Tier · 5 active · 5 closed

258 East Alegria, Sierra Madre, CA 91024

Sierra Madre · Single Family Residence

$3.99M
Luxury Tier
Beds
5
Baths
5
Sqft
5,310
Lot
20,515 sqft
Year
1910
$/Sqft
$751
Pool: Yes✓
Spa: Yes✓
View: mountain✓

Listed in line with the median closed sale of $3,900,000. Expect a longer timeline — comps averaged 140 days on market. Luxury tier — fewer comparable sales widen the confidence range.

Price Position

Aligned with the market — fair pricing for the comps.

At market
Subject listed at $3.99M· $751/sqft
Total list price
Closed comps
vs closed median $3.90M
+$88K (+2.3%)
Active comps
vs active median $3.89M
+$100K (+2.6%)
Price per sqft
Closed compsinsufficient comp data
Active comps
vs active avg $/sqft $822
−$71 (−8.7%)

Active Properties (5)

Active Comparables

AddressCityYearBDBTHSqFtLotSzLP/SqFtLPDIMScore
475 CambridgeArcadia2012564,99314,017$757$3.78M16169
725 Carriage HouseArcadia2002675,90525,720$677$4.00M1165
731 Carriage House DriveArcadia2002565,59122,579$696$3.89M5362
275 Arbolada DrArcadia1936543,96227,881$881$3.49M10962
1210 Rodeo RoadArcadia1940443,53233,987$1,101$3.89M35659
Total: 5 · Average5.05.44,796.624,836.8$822.4$3.81M138
Median4,993$3.89M

Closed Properties (5)

Closed Comparables

AddressCityYearDateBDBTHSqFtLotSzLPSPSP/SqFtSP/LPDIMScore
1328 Oaklawn RoadArcadia195405/12/2026565,03918,834$3.98M$3.98M$7901.008979
340 Arbolada DriveArcadia195008/20/2026554,36025,348$3.90M$3.90M$8941.002376
1410 Rancho RoadArcadia194105/21/2026453,95626,402$3.68M$3.70M$9351.002071
1499 Caballero RoadArcadia200605/14/2026666,55230,128$4.69M$4.10M$6260.8820870
327 Oxford DriveArcadia201612/30/2025565,27814,839$4.06M$3.90M$7390.9635969
Total: 5 · Average5.05.65,03723,110.2$3.92M$3.92M$796.8—139.8
Median5,039$3.90M$3.90M

Market Analysis

List vs Sale $/SqFt

Sale Price Trend

Days on Market

Sale vs List Price

AI-generated CMA

This analysis was generated automatically from MLS data. For an in-depth, human-reviewed valuation, contact Joseph Sardella at josephsardella@gmail.com.